Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ethan Patton's avatar

I really appreciate that when it comes to books covering historical subjects, such as the Civil War and the Mexican-American War in this issue, you tend to provide your preferred title on the subject. It's great to come away with your opinion on this title plus a recommendation on a really good alternative. My TBR list benefits a lot!

Expand full comment
John Gardner's avatar

Two good reviews Jeremy. Your position on Smith’s work is understandable. I saw the racism as well, when I read the work last year and noted as much then: https://x.com/Gardner3J/status/1624882990177308672

It’s a shame because, among other things, it detracts from a well-researched book. And while distorted, Smith does give some depth to Mexico, the key players, their motivations and maneuvering which could only come from such work.

As you wrote, you were forewarned of such histories. Even Rhodes isn’t above engaging the myth of the docile, happy slave in his aforementioned work. More are to come: I had many SMH moments in The Life and Letters of Walter Page from triple-Pulitzer winner Burton Hendrick.

What makes it still somewhat readable to me was to view these examples as history unto itself, the thesis of which is explored by Ibram Kendi in his National Book Award winning work, Stamped From the Beginning: A Definitive History of Racist Ideas in America. I read that book before reading some of these older histories and commend it to you. Not saying you won’t have more DNF - something I’m perhaps unfortunately constitutionally incapable of - but hopefully it will provide some additional background when you come across such passages.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts