22 Comments
User's avatar
Marcie Geffner | Mostly Books's avatar

My recommendations: "In the Heart of the Sea," which is fabulous and terrifying. And in poetry, "The Rime of the Ancient Mariner" by Samuel Taylor Coleridge, especially with Gustave Doré's illustrations.

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

I loved In the Heart of the Sea. Great one. And I’ve read parts of Ancient Mariner, but not the whole thing. I’ll definitely do that sometime!

Desiree Gillingham's avatar

Read:

Ship of Gold in the Deep Blue Sea

by Gary Kinder

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

I'll look it up - thanks!

EnjoyerOfReading's avatar

If you’re interested in the North American fur trade check out “The Company”, it’s a history of the Hudson Bay company and does a wonderful job describing their influence on the continent. Relevant as a new Duluthian as well as Grand Portage plays a big part in the story.

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

Oh awesome, thanks for the rec!

TraceyM's avatar

Philbrick’s “In the Heart of the Sea” is excellent. Currently reading Sancton’s “Madhouse at the End of the Earth” which is Antarctic survival, ship stuck in the ice. On the way is “The Lost Men” about Shackleton’s Ross Sea party. Shipwrecks are a fave genre, looking forward to checking out some of these recommendations ⛵️

Ryan Hall's avatar

I am the same way when it comes to books about ship wrecks. I play this game with my youngest (she made it up) when we go to a bookstore and are browsing, she likes to try to guess which books I have read or want to read. I told her every time I see a book with a shipwreck, assume I want to read it. 😂

Craig Fehrman's avatar

Excellent review! I know you're talking about nonfiction, but have you read the novel North Sun by Ethan Rutherford? I don't remember you mentioning it but maybe you have. I read it earlier this year, and I loved it not only for the endurance / harrowing conditions but for the way it was in conversation with Hawthorne, Poe, etc. A really great novel that I am trying to talk up to other readers!

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

I've not heard of that one — I'll have to check it out. Thanks Craig!

John Jackson's avatar

Skeletons of the Zahara. You're so exhausted with the shipwreck. Then the survivors get stranded in the desert and sold into slavery.

Alexander Hirtle's avatar

I have this! I'll have to go ahead and read it now :D

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

Oh man, sounds like a good one! I'll look it up.

John Gardner's avatar

Interesting you mentioned Philbrick’s book - just finished it last weekend and enjoyed it!

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

Oh nice, it's a great one! I'm well on my way to being a Philbrick completist.

Jason Hissong's avatar

LOVE shipwreck books! I second Batavia's Graveyard (and Gales, of course )I'm eyeing In the Kingdom of Ice for my next!

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

Kingdom of Ice is awesome. I listened to that one sometime last winter.

Lachie F.'s avatar

I enjoyed The Mentor, up to a point. And posted my review on Substack today. I’ll check out your recommendations and those of your subscribers. I loved The Wager and also Into the Raging Sea. A few more worth considering, not involving shipwrecks but fine maritime histories are: The Traveller by Andrea Wulf, Lightning Beneath the Sea by James Tabor, To the Edge of the World by Tilar Mazzeo and Madhouse at the End of the Earth by Julian Sancton. Slightly off-topic, but well worth reading is Canal Dreamers by Jessica Lepler.

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

Nice, I've read about half of those on your list. I'll look up the others! I enjoyed your review, as well.

Jennifer Morrow's avatar

I do like a shipwreck story, and recommend Batavia's Graveyard by Mike Dash an awful lot. I'm going to read The Wreck of the Mentor, and I'll keep your caveat in mind.

Jeremy Anderberg's avatar

Thanks for the (w)rec(k)!